Malafemmin(ist)a

By Michelle Tarnopolsky

  • Home
  • About
  • Writing
  • Interviews
  • Translation
Shary Boyle, Music for Silence, 2013

Shary Boyle, Music for Silence, 2013

Mother art at the 55th Venice Biennale

July 12, 2013 by Michelle Tarnopolsky in Art, Italy, Mother Art

I was very pleasantly surprised by how much mother art is on display at this year's Venice Biennale. My own compatriot Shary Boyle places maternalism front and centre in her piece for the Canadian pavilion, Music for Silence. I love what she told Christine Pountney about this choice here:

...what I was thinking when I made this work, was the role of aging women—and also the role of mothers. Both subjects are the least sexy and popular and fashionable to take on in the contemporary art world, where it’s all about status and hierarchy, it’s a very cool place. It’s very subtle and distinct about what people can speak about, what material, what medium. It’s not just economic—what people are buying—but what people are writing about, and what art is supposed to be: avant garde, at some level, that has status, and people want the newest thing. But it’s been very academicized for quite some time. What gets left out of that conceptual arena is the… [here she pauses and laughs incredulously] the women and the children.

Shary Boyle, Music for Silence, 2013

Shary Boyle, Music for Silence, 2013

And from this great piece by Sara Angel in the The Walrus:

Every once in a while, [Boyle] explains, her art makes people cringe, especially when, as with her installation in Venice, “it has to do with children or infants.” In Music for Silence, she will place what she describes as “a three-metre-long, 1,000-year-old plaster mermaid embracing a newborn.” As with Virus, she will project images onto it. When I ask why this might pose a problem, she counters loudly: “Come on! Who wants to deal with babies and art? It’s just not cool.” Furthermore, she adds, it will erroneously link the piece to what is now often seen as “embarrassing, out-of-date ’70s body art.” Still, the subject compels her as a feminist artist, because, she says, “Mother and child figures are so brutally overdone. They can only exist in the Catholic Church or in advertisements for soap. Artists today don’t know how to present family, childbirth, women and men. What do we do about this thing that is at the core of our life?

After reading Pountney's interview above I had high expectations, and I'm really sad to say they were not met. I LOVE Boyle's subject matter, obviously; the fact that she aims to give voice to the voiceless, that she sticks up her middle finger to the stuffy elitist contemporary art world circles that exclude mothers and children, but the work itself just didn't move me as I'd hoped it would.

And interestingly, contrary to what Boyle says above, mamma-hood seems über-hip right now if you give credence to the art-pulse-taking Biennale--arguably still the most important contemporary art exhibition in the world. With more than 50 sites all throughout the city, you simply can't see everything, even in a couple days (which I was lucky enough to have). But British artist Marc Quinn's Breath, a 35-ft tall sculpture placed on the island of San Giorgio Maggiore, is impossible to miss considering its location across the lagoon from Venice's pulsing heart, St. Mark's Square.

Marc Quinn, Breath, 2012

Marc Quinn, Breath, 2012

The piece is an inflatable replica of Quinn's 2005 Carrara-marble statue Alison Lapper Pregnant, which stood on a plinth in London's Trafalgar Square for two years and was featured in the 2012 Summer Paralympics opening ceremony. I love the dignity and monumentality Quinn has conferred upon Lapper's unconventionally beautiful body. According to the accompanying text it's meant to represent a "new model of female heroism." Bafflingly, the piece sparked criticism from the Catholic church.

Marc Quinn, Breath, 2012

Marc Quinn, Breath, 2012

Unfortunately I didn't get to see Quinn's The Way of the Flesh featuring Dutch model Lara Stone heavily pregnant and reclining on a bed of raw meat. It's part of a show dedicated to Quinn at the Fondazione Cini.

Marc Quinn, The Way of the Flesh, 2013

Marc Quinn, The Way of the Flesh, 2013

The terrific artist Cindy Sherman was tasked with curating a tiny portion of Massimiliano Gioni's main Biennale show "The Encyclopedic Palace" and her mini-exhibit features a piece called The Hidden Mother by Italian artist Linda Fregni Nagler, who spent a decade collecting 997 photos taken from the 1840's to the 1920's all presenting children whose mothers are conspicuous in their "absence."

Linda Fregni Nagler, The Hidden Mother, 2013

Linda Fregni Nagler, The Hidden Mother, 2013

I actually first learned about this widespread practice--whereby disguised mothers kept their children still while being photographed--from feminist mum blogger extraordinaire Andie Fox over a year ago, and as usual she said it best:

Sometimes you see this cultural phenomenon and it’s so perfect in explaining everything that you just think case closed.

Linda Fregni Nagler, The Hidden Mother, 2013

Linda Fregni Nagler, The Hidden Mother, 2013

However, my very favourite piece of mother art was this quiet, haunting photograph by Siberian photographer Nikolay Bakharev, one of a series of photos he took of families at the beach.

Nikolay Bakharev, N. 51, 1991-1993

Nikolay Bakharev, N. 51, 1991-1993

venice-collage.jpg
July 12, 2013 /Michelle Tarnopolsky
contemporary art, Venice Biennale, Venice, Nikolay Bakharev, Linda Fregni Nagler, Marc Quinn, Shary Boyle, Canadian pavilion
Art, Italy, Mother Art
3 Comments
  • Newer
  • Older
Featured
Motherhood studies conference in Florence next May: call for papers
Feminism, Italy, Parenting
Oct 23, 2017
Motherhood studies conference in Florence next May: call for papers
Feminism, Italy, Parenting
Oct 23, 2017
Feminism, Italy, Parenting
Oct 23, 2017
beautiful-womanhood-vintage-poster
Feminism, Italy
Jul 13, 2017
What makes a woman? A guest post by Sarah Bairstow
Feminism, Italy
Jul 13, 2017
Feminism, Italy
Jul 13, 2017
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Jun 5, 2017
A day to be proud of
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Jun 5, 2017
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Jun 5, 2017
Florence Birth Stories, Breastfeeding, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Story 6: Kate and Emma at Villa Donatello
Florence Birth Stories, Breastfeeding, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Stories, Breastfeeding, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Story 3: Miriam and Esme at home
Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Story 3: Miriam and Esme at home
Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
IMG_8184.jpg
Feminism, Italy
Mar 8, 2017
Women's Day 2017: Why I'm Striking
Feminism, Italy
Mar 8, 2017
Feminism, Italy
Mar 8, 2017
rineke-dijkstra-tecla-1994
Mother Art, Art, Pregnancy & Childbirth
Feb 6, 2017
Mother Art Monday: Rineke Dijkstra
Mother Art, Art, Pregnancy & Childbirth
Feb 6, 2017
Mother Art, Art, Pregnancy & Childbirth
Feb 6, 2017
Feminism, Italy
Dec 19, 2016
Leadership in heels
Feminism, Italy
Dec 19, 2016
Feminism, Italy
Dec 19, 2016
carabiniere_sexy.jpg
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Dec 2, 2016
The paradox of Italian masculinity
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Dec 2, 2016
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Dec 2, 2016
Feminism, Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Nov 22, 2016
Welcome (back)
Feminism, Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Nov 22, 2016
Feminism, Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Nov 22, 2016
  • Parenting
  • Art
  • Mother Art
  • LGBTQ and Gender
  • Culture Clash
  • Florence Birth Stories
  • Body Image
  • Beating the Crisi Blues
  • Uncategorized
  • Pregnancy & Childbirth
  • Quote
  • Travel
  • Feminism
  • Language
  • Race/anti-racism
  • Italy
  • Pregnancy and Childbirth
  • Bilingualism
  • Breastfeeding

Contact me

Name *
Thank you!
Archive
  • January 2010 1
  • February 2010 2
  • March 2010 2
  • April 2010 1
  • May 2010 1
  • August 2010 1
  • October 2010 2
  • January 2011 2
  • February 2011 2
  • March 2011 3
  • April 2011 1
  • May 2011 1
  • June 2011 3
  • July 2011 1
  • August 2011 1
  • January 2012 7
  • February 2012 6
  • March 2012 7
  • April 2012 6
  • May 2012 3
  • June 2012 4
  • July 2012 6
  • August 2012 11
  • September 2012 9
  • October 2012 5
  • November 2012 2
  • December 2012 3
  • January 2013 3
  • February 2013 3
  • March 2013 5
  • April 2013 3
  • May 2013 6
  • June 2013 3
  • July 2013 2
  • August 2013 2
  • September 2013 2
  • November 2013 2
  • December 2013 3
  • January 2014 3
  • March 2014 6
  • May 2014 1
  • June 2014 1
  • September 2014 1
  • October 2014 2
  • January 2015 2
  • February 2015 1
  • March 2015 1
  • May 2015 1
  • July 2016 1
  • November 2016 1
  • December 2016 2
  • February 2017 1
  • March 2017 3
  • June 2017 1
  • July 2017 1
  • October 2017 1

Subscribe

Sign up with your email address and never miss a post.

I respect your privacy.

Thank you!
  • Michelle Tarnopolsky
    “Violence against L.G.B.T. people is just another consequence of sexism. Anatomy is not a person’s destiny.” https://t.co/h833SC5Ln8
    Oct 19, 2020, 3:34 PM

Follow me on Instagram:

Empoli street shrines
Cousins 🥰 (ph @alex_sorani)
Merry Christmas!
Beyond grateful for this lot 🥰 Happy US Thanksgiving!

Powered by Squarespace

Copyright © 2020, Michelle Tarnopolsky. All rights reserved. Photos (unless stated otherwise) and content property of Michelle Tarnopolsky.