Malafemmin(ist)a

By Michelle Tarnopolsky

  • Home
  • About
  • Writing
  • Interviews
  • Translation
Belly.jpg

Peanut's birth story, part one: au naturel, Italian style

August 31, 2012 by Michelle Tarnopolsky in Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth

Throughout this nine-month journey, I’ve heard a lot of people talk about what an intense process of self-discovery pregnancy and parenting is. And how. I, for one, would never have pegged myself as one of those hardcore natural types when it came to giving birth. In the early months of pregnancy, after getting over the “holy crap, this is really happening and there’s absolutely nothing I can do to stop it” phase, I began confessing to Andrea how absolutely terrified I was of labour pain. A pretty normal response, from what I’ve gathered. It’s just amazing to me now how far I’ve come since then.

I have now spent the last three months doing as much as possible to prepare myself for a totally natural birth. And I can honestly say that today, four days before Peanut’s due date, I feel a sense of confidence and excitement I never dreamed possible. The resources out there to help women with this kind of thing really are effective. My resulting recipe includes these heartily-recommended resources: the documentary The Business of Being Born; Ina May Gaskin’s Guide to Childbirth; Pam England’s Birthing from Within; yoga; and natural-focused pre-natal classes, both the informational and physical kind.

Don’t get me wrong, I am not exactly looking forward to the pain. But I’m not dreading it either. One of the most important things I’ve learned throughout my research is the power of a positive mindset. I really believe that’s going to help me through this process. As is being totally open to peacefully accepting whatever outcome awaits us. Even if that means a cesarean section. I feel like this is key. While I hope beyond hope that Peanut’s birth will remain intervention-free until the very end, I do not want to promote feeling traumatized if that doesn’t happen.

So where are we planning this intervention-free birth? I think if I had started down this path a little earlier in my pregnancy, I would have fought harder to have a home birth, and amazingly Andrea has even come around to this idea now too. In the end, however, we’ve decided to go with what we’re hoping is the second-best option, i.e. a birthing centre staffed by midwives.

From everything I’ve continued to learn about the Italian system, I feel very lucky to even have an option like this here, one that’s taxpayer-funded to boot. The centre we’re booked with is called Margherita (which means both “daisy” and a plain, cheese-and-tomato pizza but also refers to the patron saint of birthing women) and it’s attached to the maternity ward at Careggi, Florence’s main and largest hospital.

I actually struggled for a while with this decision because of another one of those infuriating Italian paradoxes. As I’ve heard more than one Italian put it, the problem with the Margherita (if you choose it for natural-birth reasons and not because it’s like staying in a hotel), is that if anything at all goes “wrong” (i.e. even a labour that stops progressing or goes too long), you get transferred on a gurney from heaven to hell.

Careggi is indeed the very last place I would choose to birth in this city. Everyone who is in any way into natural birthing chooses Ponte a Nicheri as their hospital of choice. The midwives teaching my pre-natal classes are unabashed and shameless in their exclusive promotion of this hospital. So I had to make what felt like a rather agonizing decision between a sure-fire middle-ground and risking hell by trying to get into heaven.

So far, I’m happy to say that I’ve at least made it through the gates, which in itself is an accomplishment. I’ve heard a lot of women grumble about how strict Margherita’s acceptance policy is.  You have to be 100% risk-free and in practically perfect health.

On a related, fascinating note, upon which I plan to ruminate more in the future, the real word for “midwife” in Italian, levatrice, remains a neglected and unused relic of the past. Kind of like where we were in North America, um, forty years ago? And unlike the more enlightened languages in the rest of the western world that actually use their specific name for a person trained to assist in childbirth (my absolute favourite is the French sage femme, literally “wise woman”). Instead, Italians use the same word for a non-physician midwife and a medical obstetrician: ostetrica. Talk about confusing, not to mention a sad reflection of how Italy views this grand and honourable profession.

August 31, 2012 /Michelle Tarnopolsky
birth story, birth pain, medicalized vs. natural birth, midwifery, midwives, ostetriche, Centro Margherita, Careggi hospital, childbirth in Italy
Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth
  • Newer
  • Older
Featured
Motherhood studies conference in Florence next May: call for papers
Feminism, Italy, Parenting
Oct 23, 2017
Motherhood studies conference in Florence next May: call for papers
Feminism, Italy, Parenting
Oct 23, 2017
Feminism, Italy, Parenting
Oct 23, 2017
beautiful-womanhood-vintage-poster
Feminism, Italy
Jul 13, 2017
What makes a woman? A guest post by Sarah Bairstow
Feminism, Italy
Jul 13, 2017
Feminism, Italy
Jul 13, 2017
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Jun 5, 2017
A day to be proud of
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Jun 5, 2017
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Jun 5, 2017
Florence Birth Stories, Breastfeeding, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Story 6: Kate and Emma at Villa Donatello
Florence Birth Stories, Breastfeeding, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Stories, Breastfeeding, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Story 3: Miriam and Esme at home
Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Story 3: Miriam and Esme at home
Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
Florence Birth Stories, Italy, Pregnancy and Childbirth
Mar 22, 2017
IMG_8184.jpg
Feminism, Italy
Mar 8, 2017
Women's Day 2017: Why I'm Striking
Feminism, Italy
Mar 8, 2017
Feminism, Italy
Mar 8, 2017
rineke-dijkstra-tecla-1994
Mother Art, Art, Pregnancy & Childbirth
Feb 6, 2017
Mother Art Monday: Rineke Dijkstra
Mother Art, Art, Pregnancy & Childbirth
Feb 6, 2017
Mother Art, Art, Pregnancy & Childbirth
Feb 6, 2017
Feminism, Italy
Dec 19, 2016
Leadership in heels
Feminism, Italy
Dec 19, 2016
Feminism, Italy
Dec 19, 2016
carabiniere_sexy.jpg
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Dec 2, 2016
The paradox of Italian masculinity
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Dec 2, 2016
Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Dec 2, 2016
Feminism, Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Nov 22, 2016
Welcome (back)
Feminism, Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Nov 22, 2016
Feminism, Italy, LGBTQ and Gender
Nov 22, 2016
  • Parenting
  • Art
  • Mother Art
  • LGBTQ and Gender
  • Culture Clash
  • Florence Birth Stories
  • Body Image
  • Beating the Crisi Blues
  • Uncategorized
  • Pregnancy & Childbirth
  • Quote
  • Travel
  • Feminism
  • Language
  • Race/anti-racism
  • Italy
  • Pregnancy and Childbirth
  • Bilingualism
  • Breastfeeding

Contact me

Name *
Thank you!
Archive
  • January 2010 1
  • February 2010 2
  • March 2010 2
  • April 2010 1
  • May 2010 1
  • August 2010 1
  • October 2010 2
  • January 2011 2
  • February 2011 2
  • March 2011 3
  • April 2011 1
  • May 2011 1
  • June 2011 3
  • July 2011 1
  • August 2011 1
  • January 2012 7
  • February 2012 6
  • March 2012 7
  • April 2012 6
  • May 2012 3
  • June 2012 4
  • July 2012 6
  • August 2012 11
  • September 2012 9
  • October 2012 5
  • November 2012 2
  • December 2012 3
  • January 2013 3
  • February 2013 3
  • March 2013 5
  • April 2013 3
  • May 2013 6
  • June 2013 3
  • July 2013 2
  • August 2013 2
  • September 2013 2
  • November 2013 2
  • December 2013 3
  • January 2014 3
  • March 2014 6
  • May 2014 1
  • June 2014 1
  • September 2014 1
  • October 2014 2
  • January 2015 2
  • February 2015 1
  • March 2015 1
  • May 2015 1
  • July 2016 1
  • November 2016 1
  • December 2016 2
  • February 2017 1
  • March 2017 3
  • June 2017 1
  • July 2017 1
  • October 2017 1

Subscribe

Sign up with your email address and never miss a post.

I respect your privacy.

Thank you!
  • Michelle Tarnopolsky
    “Violence against L.G.B.T. people is just another consequence of sexism. Anatomy is not a person’s destiny.” https://t.co/h833SC5Ln8
    Oct 19, 2020, 3:34 PM

Follow me on Instagram:

Empoli street shrines
Cousins 🥰 (ph @alex_sorani)
Merry Christmas!
Beyond grateful for this lot 🥰 Happy US Thanksgiving!

Powered by Squarespace

Copyright © 2020, Michelle Tarnopolsky. All rights reserved. Photos (unless stated otherwise) and content property of Michelle Tarnopolsky.